Skip to the sample
apply.msBack to the examples
MS Rosie hiring software · Sample

Go into the interview prepared.

A scorecard gives you questions to ask and a place to record the answers. This fictional Office Manager example shows what to listen for and how to compare what you heard.

Illustrative sample in Rosie’s interview scorecard format. The role, company and candidate details are fictional.

The role

Oak Street Services is hiring an Office Manager to coordinate field schedules, keep billing accurate and give customers a dependable point of contact.

How to use it

Check the questions against the work you need done. Ask for a specific past example, what the candidate did and what happened, then ask how they would apply that experience here and what they would need to change. Record the evidence and your assessment while the conversation is fresh. Agree on essential requirements and any weighting before interviews, and use the same criteria for every candidate.

Sample · Oak Street Services · Fictional role and candidate
Metcalf SearchInterview Scorecard

One interview. One decision.

Alex Morgan
Office Manager

Can They

Do they have the skills to do this job well? Look for proof, not confidence.

  1. Tell me about a day your schedule fell apart. What did you do, and what happened?
  2. How would you use that experience to coordinate our twelve field technicians?
  3. What would need to change here, and what would you check before acting?

Listen for: A specific example, a workable transfer to this job and sensible adjustments.

Will They

Do they want this work, at this pace, for a long time? Skill without drive stalls.

  1. Why this job, and why now?
  2. Which parts of running a service office do you most want to own?
  3. How do you stay on top of routine work when the phones get busy?

Listen for: Interest in the daily work, a realistic pace and habits that keep work moving.

Fit

Will the way this job actually runs suit the way they actually work?

  1. How do you prioritize when a technician, a customer and the owner all need you?
  2. What do you need from the owner to keep the office running well?
  3. What would make you turn down this offer?

Listen for: Clear priorities, practical communication and comfort with a small team.

Locus

Accountability: what could they influence, what was outside their control, and what did they do?

  1. Tell me about a scheduling mistake you made. What did you do next?
  2. Think of an office process you changed. What would you do differently?
  3. What do you do when a customer problem has no easy answer?

Listen for: What they personally did, what others contributed and how they corrected the problem. Ask follow-up questions. Saying “I” or “we” alone does not establish accountability.

X-Factor

Anything job-related the four boxes didn't catch, good or bad. Keep it about the work. Score it like the others.

Try: "Is there anything about how you work that we didn't ask about and should have?"

Score

Area12345
Can They
Will They
Fit
Locus
X-Factor
Totalout of 25

Use the total to organize discussion, not as a hiring cutoff. Check essential job requirements separately. Investigate low or missing scores before deciding.

Decision

Move forward
Gather more evidence
Do not move forward
Metcalf Search · metcalfsearch.comScore it the same day. Decide with the sheet, not from memory.

What a rating looks like

This fictional example rates scheduling evidence only. Before the interview, the team defined a three as identifying urgent work, checking technician availability, confirming changes with customers and recording the next action.

Evidence: Alex described a sick technician, how they checked other technicians’ skills and travel times, and how they confirmed revised visits with customers. Asked about twelve technicians here, Alex proposed checking qualifications and travel time before moving visits, then updating the shared schedule.

Record the evidence and the gap

Rating: three for scheduling. The explanation meets the agreed requirement. It does not establish billing accuracy or software proficiency.

Next check: Use a short fictional scheduling exercise to see how Alex handles two urgent jobs at once. Leave unrelated skills unscored until you have evidence. A confident answer or a high total cannot fill that gap.